Status: OPEN
The Secret Garden Cafe in Jacksonville, Florida is one of Restaurant Impossible’s greatest success stories. Featured in Season 1, Episode 6, this breakfast and lunch spot has defied the odds and remained open for over 14 years since Robert Irvine’s visit – and it’s still going strong.
The Original Crisis
When Restaurant Impossible arrived in February 2011, The Secret Garden Cafe was struggling under the weight of a failing partnership. Owners Zack Nettles and Michael Williams had watched their breakfast and lunch restaurant hemorrhage money, straining both their business and personal relationship.
The cafe had been established in 1995 and built a reputation for breakfast classics like Fried Green Tomatoes and Corned Beef Hash. But years of operational issues had pushed it toward closure.
The Episode (Season 1, Episode 6)
Air Date: February 23, 2011
Designer: Vanessa Deleon (HGTV)
Robert Irvine and his team, including HGTV designer Vanessa Deleon, completed a full menu overhaul and redesign of the dining rooms in the show’s signature 48-hour timeframe.
The Transformation
Irvine focused on what made sense for a breakfast/lunch operation: streamlined menu, improved food quality, and better execution of their specialties. The physical renovation brightened up the space to match the “garden” theme that gave the cafe its name.
Perhaps more importantly, Robert addressed the partnership dynamics between Zack and Michael, helping them find a sustainable working relationship that wouldn’t destroy the business or their friendship.
Why Secret Garden Succeeded
The Secret Garden Cafe succeeded where most Restaurant Impossible restaurants failed for several key reasons:
- Smart Format: The breakfast/lunch model means lower overhead than dinner service – no late nights, no expensive dinner ingredients
- Growing Market: Jacksonville’s expanding population provided a steady customer base
- Owner Commitment: Zack and Michael actually maintained Irvine’s changes
- Community Connection: Strong local ties kept regulars coming back for over a decade
- Consistency: Open 7 days a week with reliable quality
Still Thriving Today
As of 2026, The Secret Garden Cafe continues to serve breakfast and lunch to Jacksonville residents. Recent reviews from 2024 confirm the restaurant is still operating at a high level, with particular praise for their signature dishes.
The restaurant maintains strong ratings across review platforms and has built a fiercely loyal following over its nearly three decades in business (and 14+ years since Restaurant Impossible).
Visit Information
Address: 10095 Beach Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32246
Hours: Monday-Sunday, 8:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Specialty: Fried Green Tomatoes, Corned Beef Hash, Breakfast & Sandwiches
View Secret Garden Cafe on Google Maps →
The Secret Garden Cafe stands as proof that Restaurant Impossible interventions can lead to lasting success when owners fully commit to change and maintain standards long after the cameras leave.
Last verified: January 2026
Leave a Reply