Status: CLOSED
The Seascape Inn in Islip, New York appeared on Kitchen Nightmares hoping Gordon Ramsay could save their struggling waterfront restaurant. Despite the intervention, this Long Island establishment couldn’t recover from its deep-seated problems.
Long Island Waterfront Dining
The South Shore of Long Island has dozens of waterfront restaurants competing for customers. The Seascape Inn had the location advantage but failed to capitalize on it.
What Gordon Found
The kitchen was disorganized, the menu was bloated, and the owner seemed resistant to change. These are the ingredients for Kitchen Nightmares failure.
Major Problems
- Kitchen cleanliness issues that alarmed Gordon
- Frozen seafood in a waterfront location – unacceptable
- Owner defensiveness that blocked real change
- Staff morale at rock bottom
After the Cameras Left
The Seascape Inn is one of many Kitchen Nightmares restaurants that reverted to old habits once Gordon departed. Without sustained commitment to change, the improvements didn’t stick.
The restaurant eventually closed, unable to compete with Long Island’s many excellent waterfront dining options.
Last verified: January 2026
Leave a Reply